April 9, 2024

State of the economy and economic policy play a key role in shaping migration

In this report, the CPB explores the influence of economic policy and the business cycle on migration, over a period of over seventy years. It shows that when the economy is strong, more migrants tend to arrive in the Netherlands, while during recessions, immigration decreases, and emigration increases. However, asylum migration does not show a similar relation with the business cycle. Additionally, since the 2004 EU enlargement, there has been a notable rise in immigration, primarily driven by labour and related family migration.
No title

Economic policy

Labour market flexibility, like the use of temporary contracts, encourages employers to recruit more migrant workers. For example, research indicates that lower levels of employment protection legislation lead to a higher migration balance (immigration minus emigration). It is not clear yet whether raising the minimum wage may increase or decrease immigration. Additionally, while there is no clear evidence that a more extensive social safety net is a major pull factor for migrants, this safety net did play a crucial role in the permanent settlement of guest workers in the twentieth century.

 

Lessons from the past

The report also draws a number of lessons from the guest worker history of the 1950’s, 60’s, and 70’s. Like today, the desire was to attract labour migrants temporarily, but many guest workers eventually settled permanently in the Netherlands. In the years that followed, many of the industries for which guest workers had been recruited – like textile and mining – contracted. This resulted in high levels of unemployment among guest works, who often had difficulty finding other work due to their limited schooling. Therefore, it is advisable to consider the long-term employability of migrants and to implement a migration policy that aligns with the desired direction of the Dutch economy and the corresponding labour market needs.

Authors

Photo of Bert van Stiphout-Kramer
Bert van Stiphout-Kramer +31 88 9846123 Get in touch Read more
Photo of Jan-Maarten van Sonsbeek
Jan-Maarten van Sonsbeek +31 88 9846162 Get in touch Read more